FEEDSLogin
Rights of the Child in the Context of Tourism (Hindi)  |
| December 01, 2012 |
| Across the globe, the development of tourism is raising questions as to who are its real beneficiaries... |
| Tiger Conservation Guidelines Do Not Promote Sustainable Tourism |
| October 16, 2012 |
 |
| The comprehensive guidelines for tiger conservation and tourism issued by... |
| Activists Write To Minister Against New Tiger Tourism Norms |
| October 02, 2012 |
 |
| Two members of a National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) panel set up to... |
| Eco-Tourism Guidelines Submitted In Court Misleading MoEF Panel Members |
| October 02, 2012 |
 |
| Two members of the panel set up by the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) to... |
| Caught In The Fire |
| August 25, 2012 |
 |
| Mobile phones were on vibrate mode and buzzing with... |
EQUATIONS' Response to the National PPP Policy, 2011(Draft)
January 01, 1970
Click here to download 'EQUATIONS' Response to the National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft)-13 October 2011-EQUATIONS', 80.8kb. The same can be read below.
Click here to download 'EQUATIONS’ Response to National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft) Announced by Dept of Economic Affairs-13 October 2011', 149kb.
EQUATIONS' Response to the National PPP Policy, 2011(Draft)-13 October 2011-EQUATIONS
13 October 2011
EQUATIONS' Response to the National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft)Announced by the Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance, Government of India
The Ministry of Finance issued the draft National PPP Policy, 2011 on September 27th and had invited comments/suggestions by October 15th. EQUATIONS has submitted it comments from the point of view of tourism. There are 5 key inadequacies/issues that need to be addressed: inadequate review for the need for PPPs, inadequate impact studies on PPPs, PPPs are driven by economic interests and returns on investment, impacting the access of under-privileged to basic services like health and education, clubbing of all tourism projects as public purpose being problematic as many of the PPP projects are in the high-end sectors and finally lack of basic documentation on the outcomes of existing PPP projects. While highlighting these issues, the comments also propose specific changes that need to be made in the text of the policy.
To, 13 October 2011
Mr. Pranab Mukherjee,
Minister of Finance
North Block
New Delhi
Dear Mr. Mukherjee,
Subject: EQUATIONS' Response to the National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft)
Greetings from EQUATIONS!
EQUATIONS welcomes the initiative of the Department of Economic Affairs to formulate a long
overdue national policy governing Public Private Partnerships (PPPs).
Enclosed are our comments and response to the policy draft. We find that while the economic and
financial aspects of PPPs have been given due consideration, the policy falls short in terms of
transparency, accountability and the space for eliciting and upholding people's responses to the
PPP projects.
Specifically in the context of tourism, it is extremely important that the sector as a whole not
be considered as public purpose and that instead, only projects covering basic services like
shelters, bus stops, budget hotels, sanitation be categorised as such. Their should be no
involvement of the Government in high-end tourism projects which should be left to the private
sector initiatives.
While the government has initiated this process, it is nowhere near sufficient. Spaces for
vibrant public debates should be facilitated on this issue before finalisation. Therefore, we
recommend that the Ministry extend the deadline for receiving comments and responses from people
and that this policy not be passed until diverse stakeholders have responded to the draft.
Looking forward to action by Ministry on the critical issues that have been raised.
Yours sincerely,
Swathi Seshadri
Programme Coordinator
EQUATIONS
Copy to:
1. Secretary, Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance
2. Secretary, Ministry of Tourism
Encl:
1. EQUATIONS’ Response to National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft) Announced by Dept of Economic
Affairs-13 October 2011
Contact Us:
campaigns@equitabletourism.org, info@equitabletourism.org
+91 (80) 23659711 / 23659722
EQUATIONS, Flat no - A2, 1st floor, No 21/7, 2nd Cross, 1st A Main Road, Atmananda Colony, Sultan
Palya, R T Nagar Post, Bengaluru - 560032, Karnataka, India
URL: www.equitabletourism.org
Click here to download 'EQUATIONS’ Response to National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft) Announced by Dept of Economic Affairs-13 October 2011', 149kb.
EQUATIONS' Response to the National PPP Policy, 2011(Draft)-13 October 2011-EQUATIONS
13 October 2011
EQUATIONS' Response to the National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft)Announced by the Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance, Government of India
The Ministry of Finance issued the draft National PPP Policy, 2011 on September 27th and had invited comments/suggestions by October 15th. EQUATIONS has submitted it comments from the point of view of tourism. There are 5 key inadequacies/issues that need to be addressed: inadequate review for the need for PPPs, inadequate impact studies on PPPs, PPPs are driven by economic interests and returns on investment, impacting the access of under-privileged to basic services like health and education, clubbing of all tourism projects as public purpose being problematic as many of the PPP projects are in the high-end sectors and finally lack of basic documentation on the outcomes of existing PPP projects. While highlighting these issues, the comments also propose specific changes that need to be made in the text of the policy.
To, 13 October 2011
Mr. Pranab Mukherjee,
Minister of Finance
North Block
New Delhi
Dear Mr. Mukherjee,
Subject: EQUATIONS' Response to the National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft)
Greetings from EQUATIONS!
EQUATIONS welcomes the initiative of the Department of Economic Affairs to formulate a long
overdue national policy governing Public Private Partnerships (PPPs).
Enclosed are our comments and response to the policy draft. We find that while the economic and
financial aspects of PPPs have been given due consideration, the policy falls short in terms of
transparency, accountability and the space for eliciting and upholding people's responses to the
PPP projects.
Specifically in the context of tourism, it is extremely important that the sector as a whole not
be considered as public purpose and that instead, only projects covering basic services like
shelters, bus stops, budget hotels, sanitation be categorised as such. Their should be no
involvement of the Government in high-end tourism projects which should be left to the private
sector initiatives.
While the government has initiated this process, it is nowhere near sufficient. Spaces for
vibrant public debates should be facilitated on this issue before finalisation. Therefore, we
recommend that the Ministry extend the deadline for receiving comments and responses from people
and that this policy not be passed until diverse stakeholders have responded to the draft.
Looking forward to action by Ministry on the critical issues that have been raised.
Yours sincerely,
Swathi Seshadri
Programme Coordinator
EQUATIONS
Copy to:
1. Secretary, Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance
2. Secretary, Ministry of Tourism
Encl:
1. EQUATIONS’ Response to National PPP Policy, 2011 (Draft) Announced by Dept of Economic
Affairs-13 October 2011
Contact Us:
campaigns@equitabletourism.org, info@equitabletourism.org
+91 (80) 23659711 / 23659722
EQUATIONS, Flat no - A2, 1st floor, No 21/7, 2nd Cross, 1st A Main Road, Atmananda Colony, Sultan
Palya, R T Nagar Post, Bengaluru - 560032, Karnataka, India
URL: www.equitabletourism.org